The short answer
The choice is less about quality than about the shape of the work. Steady, never-finished work on a product suits an employee. A project with a beginning and an end suits an outside team. Most businesses have some of each, which is why the question keeps coming back.
There is also a middle route, where outside developers work inside your team for an agreed period. We offer that ourselves, so this guide comes from doing the work, and it sets out all three options fairly.
What each option really is
An in-house developer is an employee. They work only on your systems, learn the business deeply and are there every day. You carry the salary, the recruitment, the management and the risk if they leave.
An agency is a company you pay to deliver defined work. You get a team with several skills and a contract with a scope. When the project ends, so does the cost, and usually so does the day-to-day knowledge.
An embedded arrangement places outside developers inside your team. They join your meetings, use your tools and work to your priorities, but they are not on your payroll. Storm's embedded engineering service works this way, with George and Nicholas working directly with your team.
How the three compare
| In-house | Agency | Embedded | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best for | A product that never stops changing | A defined project | Ongoing work that needs context |
| Time to start | Slow: recruit, then train | Quick, once scoped | Quick, once priorities are agreed |
| Range of skills | One person's | A team's | The outside team's, inside yours |
| Where knowledge sits | With you, while they stay | Mostly with the agency | Shared, if documented |
| Commitment | Open-ended | Ends with the project | An agreed period |
| Your management time | High | Low to moderate | Moderate |
When an in-house developer is the right call
Hire when the software is part of what makes your business different and it will need attention every week for years. The knowledge an employee builds up is the asset, and you want it to stay.
- You sell software, or your service depends on a system you own.
- There is a steady backlog, not a one-off list.
- Someone in the business can manage and review technical work.
- You can afford the months it takes to recruit and get a new starter productive.
Be honest about the last two. A lone developer with nobody to review their work, and no cover when they are away, is a risk as well as an asset.
When an agency is the right call
Use an agency when you can describe what finished looks like. A new website, a customer portal or an integration between two systems all have an end. You want a team to arrive, deliver and hand over.
- The work needs design, development and testing, not one skill.
- There is a deadline your own team cannot meet.
- You do not need the capacity once the project is done.
Our guide on when to outsource development goes further into which kinds of work are safe to hand over and which are not.

When the middle route makes sense
Embedded work suits a business that has ongoing development to do but not enough to justify a hire, or one that needs extra hands alongside an existing developer. The outside team learns your systems and stays long enough for that to pay off.
It is not the same as hiring a contractor for a task. Our comparison of freelancer vs embedded developer explains the difference.
Cost, without the guesswork
Comparing a salary with a day rate is misleading. An employee costs more than their salary once you add recruitment, equipment, software, holidays, training and the time of whoever manages them. An outside team costs more per day and nothing when there is no work.
The fair comparison is cost per finished piece of work over a year, including the weeks when an employee would have had too little to do or an agency would have been waiting for your feedback.
Whichever you choose, protect yourself
- Keep the code, the hosting and the accounts in your company's name.
- Ask for documentation as part of the work, not as an extra.
- Make sure more than one person understands each system.
- Agree in writing who owns what before work starts.
These apply to websites as much as to software. If the project is a website, our guide on website agency vs freelancer covers the same decision on a smaller scale.
Five questions that usually settle it
- Could you write down what finished looks like? If yes, it is a project.
- Will the work still be there in two years? If yes, it may be a role.
- Does it need more than one skill? If yes, one hire will not cover it.
- Is there someone to manage and review a developer? If not, a lone hire is exposed.
- What happens if the person or supplier disappears? Whatever the answer, plan for it.
Answer them for each piece of work, not for the business as a whole. It is normal to end up with a mix: a project handed to an outside team this year, and a role created once the ongoing work is understood.
Making a handover work
Whichever route you take, there will be a moment when knowledge has to move from one set of hands to another. Plan it at the start, not the end.
Ask for the system to be explained to a named person in your business, in plain words, with a written record. Ask for a short period after delivery when questions are answered. Check that you can log in to everything yourself before the final invoice is paid.
Common mistakes
- Hiring a developer for a project that will be finished in three months.
- Giving an agency an open-ended product with no clear scope.
- Relying on one person who holds everything in their head.
- Choosing on day rate without counting the work delivered.
- Leaving the code and accounts in a supplier's name.
Common questions
Can we start with an agency and hire later?
Yes, and it is a common path. An outside team builds the first version, you learn what the ongoing work really is, then you hire with a clear job to offer. Plan the handover from the start.
Is an in-house developer cheaper in the long run?
Only if there is enough work to keep them fully and usefully busy. If the workload rises and falls, paying for capacity when you need it often works out better.
What if our developer leaves?
That is the main risk of a single hire. Documentation, shared access and a second person who knows the system reduce it. An outside team working alongside can provide that cover.
What to do next
List the development work you expect over the next year and mark each item as a project with an end or ongoing work. The balance between the two usually answers the question.
If part of that list is a website that is not pulling its weight, ask for our free 24-hour audit. A founder records a personal video walkthrough of your website within 24 hours. No call is needed.
Want this applied to your website?
George or Nicholas will record a personal walkthrough of your site within 24 hours.
Not ready for an audit? See Embedded engineering.
