The short answer
Agencies are easy to find and hard to compare. Most say similar things, show similar logos and promise growth. The differences that matter are practical: who does the work, what is written down and what you own at the end.
This guide gives you five checks and the questions behind each one. We are a founder-led studio, so we have a view, but the checks apply to any supplier, including us.
Start with the problem, not the agency
Before you speak to anyone, write down what you want to change. More enquiries, better enquiries, less admin or a website that reflects the business are four different briefs, and they suit different suppliers.
- What is the outcome you want in plain words?
- How will you know it has happened?
- What have you tried already, and what did it show?
- Who inside the business will give feedback and approve the work?
If the brief is more enquiries, look closely at how an agency describes its lead generation service. It should cover what happens after the click as well as how people find you.
The five checks
| Check | What to ask | A good sign |
|---|---|---|
| Work you can inspect | Can I see live projects for a business like mine? | Real websites you can visit, with the client named |
| Who does the work | Who will I speak to, and who builds it? | You meet the people doing the work before you sign |
| Scope and price | What exactly is included, and what is not? | A written scope and one clear price |
| Measurement | How will we both know it is working? | Enquiries and customers, tied to a source |
| Ownership | Who owns the site, accounts and data? | Set out in writing before work starts |
Who actually does the work
In many agencies the person who sells the project is not the person who delivers it. That is not wrong, but you should know. Ask to meet whoever will plan, build and answer your messages.
Size is a trade-off, not a quality mark. A larger agency has more specialists and more layers. A smaller studio gives you direct contact and less cover if someone is away. Our guide on marketing agency vs in-house marketing team sets out a third option, which is building the skills yourself.
Proof you can check
Ask for live work, not a slide of logos. Visit the websites on your phone. Search for the client and see how they appear. If the agency quotes a result, ask how it was measured and over what period.
Reviews help most when they are detailed and on a platform the agency does not control. Our list of questions to ask a web design agency includes the ones that tend to reveal how a project will really run.

Contracts, ownership and access
Most disputes start with something nobody wrote down. Read the agreement before you agree the price, not after.
- Who owns the website, the content and the design files.
- Whose name the domain, hosting, analytics and advertising accounts are in.
- The notice period, and what happens to your assets if you leave.
- Which third-party licences the work depends on, and who pays for them.
- How changes outside the scope are priced.
What it should cost
Prices vary widely because scope varies widely. A fair quote explains what you are paying for and what would change it. Be cautious of a figure given before anyone has asked about your business.
It helps to arrive with a budget range. Our guide on how much to spend on digital marketing shows how to work one out from the value of a customer. For reference, Storm websites start from £2,500 for a small, focused site and most projects cost more, priced on scope and agreed in writing before work starts.
How to run the selection
A simple process keeps the decision fair and stops you being swayed by the best presenter.
- Write a one-page brief: the problem, the outcome you want, your budget range and your timescale.
- Send the same brief to three suppliers, not ten.
- Ask each for a short call with the person who would do the work.
- Ask for a written proposal covering scope, price, timings and ownership.
- Call one past client of each, and ask what went wrong as well as what went right.
Pay attention to how each supplier behaves before you are a client. Slow replies, vague answers and pressure to sign quickly rarely improve after the contract starts.
What a good first month looks like
The first month of a new relationship tells you most of what you need to know. You should have a named contact, an agreed plan with dates, access to anything set up in your name and a clear idea of what you are expected to provide.
You should also have been asked hard questions about your business: who your best customers are, what an enquiry is worth and where work comes from today. A supplier who does not ask is planning to guess. If the first month is mostly silence, say so early and ask for the plan in writing.
Common mistakes
- Choosing on price alone, then paying again to fix it.
- Signing a long contract before any work has been seen.
- Accepting a guarantee of rankings or results. No honest supplier can give one.
- Letting the agency register the domain and accounts in its own name.
- Judging monthly reports by their length instead of by enquiries.
Common questions
Should the agency be local?
It does not have to be, but it can help. Meeting in person makes the brief easier, and a local agency tends to know the area you sell in. Good work matters more than distance.
Is a specialist better than a generalist?
A specialist in your sector will ask better questions sooner. A generalist may bring ideas from elsewhere. Either can work if the published projects show they understand how your customers buy.
How long should we commit for?
A project such as a website has a natural end. Ongoing work such as search visibility needs months to show its value. Ask for a notice period that lets you leave if the work is not being done.
What if we have been burned before?
Say so. A good supplier will ask what went wrong and show you how their process prevents it. If they are dismissive, that tells you something as well.
What to do next
Shortlist three suppliers and put the same five checks to each. Compare the answers side by side, in writing. The gaps are usually obvious.
If you would like to see how we work before deciding anything, ask for our free 24-hour audit. A founder records a personal video walkthrough of your website within 24 hours. No call is needed, and the notes are yours to keep whoever you choose.
Want this applied to your website?
George or Nicholas will record a personal walkthrough of your site within 24 hours.
Not ready for an audit? See Lead generation.
